One of my first posts to this blog was the great debate between Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta for the Horse of the Year title. If you have read the previous post,
Rachel Alexandra v. Zenyatta [HOTY], you may have noticed how I presented the facts for one of these fillies - and clearly expressed why Rachel was the champion of the year, and not Zenyatta.
Was I alone? Oh goodness no! Those who follow horse racing have noticed two camps: one for Rachel and one for Zen. Regardless of which camp you were for, you all had your reasons. "Zenyatta is going to retire undefeated, a perfect fourteen-fourteen, after the Classic even!" was one response from the Zenyatta camp. Rachel? "Eight races, all perfect wins, winning by a combined total of nearly seventy lengths, and winning not once, not twice,
but three times against males both her age and older."
Was I alone, in proclaiming Rachel as the better of the fillies? No. Was it obviously a close race? Let's head over to my favorite site for horse racing - the National Thoroughbred Racing Association. In their article,
Rachel Alexandra wins Horse of the Year, they state that Rachel received 130 first-place votes, as compared to Zenyatta's 99. "
All three voting blocs went for Rachel Alexandra. The National Turf Writers Association preferred Rachel Alexandra by 71 votes to 51. Daily Racing Form went for Rachel Alexandra by a 31-23 margin. And the National Thoroughbred Racing Association, which includes racing secretaries and members of Equibase, had Rachel Alexandra by 28-25."
The closest of these races was at the NTRA itself; a mere three vote margin separated these two powerhouse fillies. Now, many question why did Zenyatta loose? My thoughts:
1) Zenyatta's career was fantastic, but her 2009 season consisted of only five starts, with the Classic being her only highlight.
2) Zenyatta is returning to racing. I found this a damaging blow to her campaign for HOTY.
3) Zenyatta can only claim the Classic - yes, in fact it is marvelous - but Rachel raced three times against colts this year, even holding off older colt Macho Again.